Colin Barnett has declared the increasing use of illegal drugs - in combination with binge drinking - is at the heart of Perth's record of street violence.
-The West Australian
Er, sorry Colin but drugs alone rarely cause people to be violent. Booze has officially taken that honour. In fact, alcohol is by far, the most violent drug on earth. Never before in the history of man has a drug proven to cause so much violence, aggression and crime. And to top it off, it's legal, easy to buy and heavily endorsed by celebrities, sports stars and politicians.
How many people do you know who become violent on ecstasy, cannabis or heroin? Even the so called "ice epidemic" causing violence is a myth.
Interviewer: My guests today in Melbourne University Up Close are Associate Professor John Fitzgerald and Dr. Fances Bramwell.
So, John, essentially what you are saying is that, in Australia there is no epidemic of ice use.
Associate Professor John Fitzgerald, Principal Research Fellow at the School of Population Health, University of Melbourne: Yeah, and it is not to say that ice use is not problematic.
Alcohol accounts for 97% of all violence whilst under the influence of a substance. Illicit drugs ranks a lowly 3%. And out of that 3%, sleep depravation from amphetamine type drugs is responsible for half of that, not the violent reaction from the drug itself. With less than 1.5% of substance induced violence associated to illicit drugs, it is easy to assume that 99% of those classed as being aggressive are naturally violent regardless of any substance they may have taken.
Drinking is not new - and I don't defend or excuse that in any sense. But excessive drinking and combining with drugs is clearly leading to more violent behaviour
-Colin Barnett
Any drug taker will tell you the simple truth ... drugs cause the opposite reaction of being violent. Many of them bring on confidence, friendship, empathy, sexuality, pleasantness, a need to communicate, feelings of euphoria, camaraderie etc. Other drugs make you drowsy and uninterested in anything confrontational. Others will make you "trip" where everything around you becomes magical and exciting. No drug I know of gives the user any need to be aggressive or violent ... except booze.
But what clearly stands out in this article is the contradictory comments by the premier compared to those who actually patrol the streets - The Police.
WA Police have emphasised alcohol rather than drugs in the debate about violence in entertainment precincts that has raged after recent tragic incidents in Northbridge and Cottesloe.
Operation Unite commander Supt Scott Higgins said the root of violence was complex but alcohol was a consistent theme.
-The West Australian
Is this because the premier's drug of choice is booze ... A dangerous drug that harms people thousands of times more often than street drugs?
"With people drinking in parks, homes, in pubs and clubs, whether they're taking drugs or not taking drugs, the consistent thing is alcohol," he said.
-The West Australian
Or is it because the drug he prefers to use causes far more carnage to society than any illicit drug?
What I really want to know is why the opposition and the media has not challenged Barnett to these ludicrous claims? There is no evidence whatsoever or scientific report ever produced that associates the effects of illicit drugs with excessive violence. In fact, there are only two examples of violence resulting from drugs. One is when drugs are used in conjunction with alcohol and the other is in the business side of selling drugs. Ironically, both of these are purely the result of government policy.
I'm sorry Colin but you are once again on record, lying about the issue of illicit drugs. Are you really that arrogant that you think the vast majority of Western Australians don't have the ability to check your claims on the internet? Or are you just so out of touch with reality that you think the internet is just some gizmo from a sc-fi novel? My guess is that you know darn well that the failed policy of drug prohibition has wreaked havoc on society for nearly 50 years but since it continues to win you votes, you will keep pretending to support it. And we wonder why the public thinks that Australian politics has gone to shit?
Premier Says Drugs Have Role In Violence
Gareth Parker And Gabrielle Knowles,
May 2011
Colin Barnett has declared the increasing use of illegal drugs - in combination with binge drinking - is at the heart of Perth's record of street violence.
As WA Police continued to emphasise the role of alcohol amid a weekend crackdown that saw 435 people charged in Operation Unite, the Premier said drinking had always been an issue but the level of illegal drug taking was new.
He also suggested young West Australians' higher incomes relative to the rest of the nation could be fuelling the drug abuse.
"There is no doubt income levels in WA are probably $20,000 more than the rest of the country and there are a lot of people, often young people, who are on high incomes," Mr Barnett said.
"Many of them might be fly-in, fly-out mine workers who are in Perth in their week off, they have a lot of money to spend and they party too hard.
"Drinking is not new - and I don't defend or excuse that in any sense. But excessive drinking and combining with drugs is clearly leading to more violent behaviour."
WA Police have emphasised alcohol rather than drugs in the debate about violence in entertainment precincts that has raged after recent tragic incidents in Northbridge and Cottesloe.
Operation Unite commander Supt Scott Higgins said the root of violence was complex but alcohol was a consistent theme.
"With people drinking in parks, homes, in pubs and clubs, whether they're taking drugs or not taking drugs, the consistent thing is alcohol," he said.
At the weekend, police charged 435 people with 462 offences, including 391 traffic offences, 10 assaults and five assaults on public officers.
Supt Higgins said police were most concerned by the number of motorists drink-driving, with 138 caught driving over the limit, including 18 charged with driving under the influence.
In addition, a Victoria Park man has been charged over a one-punch assault in Northbridge that left a 26-year-old with head injuries.
The man hit his head on the pavement and lost consciousness after he was allegedly king-hit outside the Republic Nightclub in Shafto Lane about 12.30am on Saturday.
Police claim the attacker, also 26, was thrown out of the nightclub seconds earlier and allegedly punched the other man after mistaking him for someone else.
NOTE:
Colin Barnett was the winner of the 2009 Bucket Head of the Year award. Here it is again just to refresh your memory.
THE BUCKETHEAD OF THE YEAR - 2009
The ultimate anti-drug zealot who made a huge impact on the downfall of rational thinking and sensibility in 2009. Unlike the category for Most Dangerous Anti-Drug Campaigner, The Bucket Head of the Year can be literally a “Bucket Head” Think of Rove, Bronwyn Bishop, Daryl Somers etc. They might be dangerous or just plain stupid but they must be worthy of scorn and criticism.
Colin Barnett
WA Premier (LP)
Trying to top last year’s winner, Anne Bressington, is not easy but WA premier, Colin Barnett has made a gallant attempt. Introducing new laws infamous for failing globally, to replace existing laws that have been succeeding could be interpreted as brave and insightful. Unfortunately for Colin “Barney Rubble” Barnett, it wasn’t. It was seen for what it really was ... an out-of-touch old man clinging desperately to his stagnant ideology and putting faith into strategies that have failed miserably for the last 40-60 years which are rapidly on their way out. Only a brave man indeed would remove a modern, successful drug policy because of myths like “The Gateway Theory” and other junk science. Someone should point out to Barney that the internet(yes Barney, that TV looking thing on your desk) means politicians can no longer just say what they want and the public have to take it as gospel.
Barney is also introducing “Stop and Search” laws, claiming it will cut down on street violence and anti-social behaviour by seeking out those carrying knives or drugs. In certain designated areas, police can stop and search any person without provision of reasonable suspicion. What the hell drugs have to with weapons is yet to quantified.
Barney is a dying breed which probably sums up the current Liberal Party and some of the Labor Party. It's not that his drug policies are just useless and counter-productive but they are also dangerous. To underplay the deaths and misery caused by these policies for political gain or for personal ideology is disgraceful and should be seen as a criminal act. A “Tough on Drugs” mentality has caused massive damage in every country that adopts this approach and after 100 years of drug prohibition globally, some common sense is finally emerging. Sadly, this doesn’t include Colin Barnett.
On a lighter side ... man, is he funny or what? That bloodhound face looking like it was made from plastic. The monotone political rhetoric putting TV viewers to sleep. Walking around Northbridge at night to prove it is family friendly only to be confronted with some druggie asleep in a doorway. But it was an accidental camera pan of several heavyweight body guards that blew his cover as the brave leader walking the streets alone. And of course, the references to old, debunked urban myths about drugs that had much of WA’s youth rolling around the floor in hysterics and experts scratching their heads in bewilderment. Good stuff, Barney.
I proudly present to you, this years BucketHead of the Year for 2009 ... WA Premier, Colin Barnett.
Related Articles
3 comments:
Don't they have a crack epidemic in Australia? I read that memoir In My Skin by Kate Holden and noticed in her 5 years of heroin addiction she never tried crack once, or injected cocaine. I was addicted to the heroin-coke speedball mixture. It amps up the effects of both considerably.
Ice hasn't come over here. If I were a drug dealer I'd specialize in crystal meth. I reckon you'd make a fortune out of that. Here people use dire-quality cocaine. There was a craze for 4MMC which I tried once and it blows cocaine out of the water. Amazingly strong stuff. I took 200mg of the pure drug. Wow!
I did see a film of a man on a roof in Thailand going mad. That was supposedly yaba.
My friend Anna ended up in hospital with a bipolar manic episode and they were convinced she was on crystal meth. Having been manic and having taken speed I wonder how stupid these hospitals are. Speed doesn't really cause racing thoughts like mania does. Speed psychosis causes extreme paranoia whereas mania usually makes you grandiose and euphoric. When I used to take uppers I'd find myself staring into space rocking. Mania makes you pace and move about all over the place. Surely if I can put my finger on these differences, the medical profession should be able to. They're crap crap crap!
And as for politicians... your lot sound even worse than ours. Bloody wastes of space, the lot of them.
4MMC is 4methylmethcathinone, socalled meow or mepherdrone and I can never spell that word which is too similar to "methadone" for my liking. Which is why I call it 4MMC or meow.
Another great post Terry.
Thanks for digging up the facts. You're spot on to note opposition apathy. It seems pop culture bollocks is the default political, voter-safe position. Never mind - we can always build more prisons for these violent thugs.
When it comes to King Hits, I do know some pot smokers who like to hit Burger King late at night. Does that qualify? Violent dreams? Vomiting violently?
As a former Bucketeer he's reinforcing his status. What always gets moi is the absence of woe and horror in the medicated population that is ignored. Surely we'd see analogues of street drugs pulled off the market.
Choosing to dose up on benzo's can lead to disinhibition and some antisocial behaviour but those on Rx meds also vote in greater numbers. In fact not medicating some citizens leads to tragedy for them and others.
And to think he could have used that rhetoric window to comment on mental health or gambling.
Post a Comment